Skip to content

8BitDo Arcade Stick vs. Mayflash F500: A Comprehensive Comparison for Gamers

May 23, 2023
8BitDo Arcade Stick vs. Mayflash F500

Arcade sticks have become essential gaming accessories for avid gamers, delivering an authentic arcade experience in the comfort of their own homes. When it comes to choosing the perfect arcade stick, two popular options often come up for discussion: the 8BitDo Arcade Stick and the Mayflash F500. In this article, we will compare these two renowned arcade sticks to help you make an informed decision based on your gaming preferences.

Specification8BitDo Arcade StickMayflash F500
CompatibilityNintendo Switch, Windows, macOS, Android, Raspberry PiPS4, PS3, Xbox One, Xbox 360, PC, Android, Nintendo Switch
ConnectivityWireless and wiredWired
Button QualityHigh-quality buttonsHigh-quality Sanwa buttons (upgradeable)
CustomizationModerate, software customizationHigh, button and stick are modifiable
JoystickStandard Ball TopSanwa JLF clone (upgradeable)
Weight2.1 kg3 kg
Battery Life (Wireless)40 hoursN/A
ProsHigh-quality components, versatile compatibility, wireless functionalityHighly customizable, multi-platform compatibility, sturdy build
ConsLimited physical customization options, lighter weight may not suit all playersHigher price point, wired only

Design and Build Quality

Both the 8BitDo Arcade Stick and the Mayflash F500 feature a sturdy construction designed to withstand intense gaming sessions. The 8BitDo Arcade Stick showcases a retro-inspired design reminiscent of classic arcade cabinets, complete with a compact form factor. On the other hand, the Mayflash F500 boasts a more modern and versatile design with customizable artwork and a larger footprint. Depending on your preference, you can choose between a nostalgic or contemporary aesthetic.

Features and Compatibility

When it comes to features, both arcade sticks offer impressive functionalities. The 8BitDo Arcade Stick supports wireless Bluetooth connectivity, making it compatible with various platforms, including Nintendo Switch, Windows, macOS, and Android. It also includes a rechargeable battery, allowing for extended gaming sessions without interruptions.

The Mayflash F500, on the other hand, focuses on versatility. It features multi-platform compatibility, supporting consoles such as PlayStation 4, Xbox One, Nintendo Switch, and PC. Additionally, the F500 offers the option to connect other arcade sticks, gamepads, or even a keyboard through its USB ports, catering to diverse gaming preferences.

Performance and Customization

When it comes to performance, both arcade sticks deliver smooth and responsive gameplay. The 8BitDo Arcade Stick utilizes high-quality Sanwa Denshi buttons and joystick, providing a satisfying tactile feedback. Its compact size and ergonomic design make it suitable for players with smaller hands.

The Mayflash F500 offers excellent responsiveness with its own set of quality buttons and joystick. Additionally, it provides the option to customize the joystick and buttons, allowing players to swap them with their preferred brand or style. This customization feature is particularly appealing for gamers who prioritize personalization.

Price and Value

In terms of pricing, the 8BitDo Arcade Stick generally falls within a more affordable range, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious gamers. Despite its lower price point, it doesn’t compromise on quality or performance, delivering a great gaming experience.

The Mayflash F500 tends to have a slightly higher price due to its expanded compatibility and customization options. However, for gamers who require multi-platform support and the ability to personalize their arcade stick, the Mayflash F500 offers excellent value for the price.

Mayflash F500 vs

8BitDo Arcade Stick and the Mayflash F500

In conclusion, both the 8BitDo Arcade Stick and the Mayflash F500 have their unique strengths and cater to different gaming preferences. If you value a compact and retro design, wireless Bluetooth connectivity, and compatibility with Nintendo Switch and various platforms, the 8BitDo Arcade Stick is an excellent choice.

On the other hand, if you prioritize versatility, multi-platform compatibility, and customization options, the Mayflash F500 is a compelling option. Its ability to connect other arcade sticks, gamepads, or even a keyboard expands its usability and caters to a broader range of gaming setups.

Ultimately, your decision should be based on your specific gaming needs, preferences, and budget. Consider factors such as design, features, compatibility, performance, and customization options to choose the perfect arcade stick that enhances your gaming experience.

Features8BitDo Arcade StickMayflash F500
ConnectivityWireless via 2.4GHz and Bluetooth, plus wired optionWired only
CompatibilityNintendo Switch, Windows, Android, Raspberry Pi, FPGANintendo Switch, PS3, PS4, PS5 (for PS4 games), Xbox 360, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S, Playstation Classic, Sega Genesis Classic, Neo Geo Mini
ModdabilityFeatures a universal mounting plate, providing many options for different sticks. Requires a Torx tool to open.Quite standard when it comes to mods, and easy to open with a Phillips screwdriver.
Size and WeightSmaller compared to Mayflash F500Larger compared to 8BitDo Arcade Stick
Parts/ComponentsGeneric componentsMayflash F500 Elite comes with Sanwa components
Support for classic devicesWorks on PlayStation Classic, but has not been tested on other miniconsolesWorks on PlayStation Classic, Sega Genesis Classic, and comes with an adapter for Neo Geo Mini
Connection optionsVarious connection options via Bluetooth, 2.4GHz and wiredWired only
Need for additional controllers or adaptersNot necessary for regular useNeeds an additional controller or Mayflash Magic Adapter to work on PS4, Xbox One, Xbox Series X and PS5 (with PS4 games)
Customization/ModdingCustomization is more complicated than on the Mayflash F500Customization is simpler than on the 8BitDo Arcade Stick

Remember to carefully weigh the pros and cons of each arcade stick and consider reading customer reviews and feedback to gain insights from other gamers who have used these products. By doing so, you can make an informed decision and invest in an arcade stick that will provide you with countless hours of enjoyable gaming.

  • Materials: While both Arcade Controllers are solidly built, the F500 has a metal top and bottom panel, making it sturdier than the plastic version of the 8BitDo.
  • Size: The F500 is slightly larger than the 8BitDo Arcade Stick, and that’s clear from its weight of 2.1Kgs versus 2.96Kgs. The 8BitDo has dimensions of 30.3cmX20.3cmX11.15cm, compared to the F500’s 58.98cmX42.49X30cm. While the F500 is larger, the 8BitDo has a very good hand feel.
  • Buttons and Levers Compatibility: Both compatible with Sanwa and Seimitsu 20mm and 24mm and with levers Compatible with Sanwa and Seimitsu competition.
  • Connectivity: The clear winner is the 8Bitdo that allows you to connect by the same means as the F500, but adds the great possibility of doing it without cables, through Bluetooth, which is very convenient.
  • PC Operating System Compatibility: Both have great compatibility. The F500 adds the ability to support older systems like Windows XP and Vista, which in our view wouldn’t help much.
  • Nintendo Switch Compatibility: Both are compatible.
  • Playstation and Xbox compatibility: Only the F500 is compatible with these systems

So whether you opt for the nostalgic charm of the 8BitDo Arcade Stick or the versatility of the Mayflash F500, both options will bring you closer to an authentic arcade gaming experience right in your own living room.